Advantages and disadvantages of natural dyes/ colouants :

Advantages of natural dyes/ colouants

i. The shades produced by natural dyes/colourants are usually soft, lustrous and soothing to the human eye.

ii. Natural dyestuff can produce a wide range of colours by mix and match system. A small variation in the dyeing technique or the use of different mordants with the same dye (polygenetic type natural dye) can shift the colours to a wide range or create totally new colours, which are not easily possible with synthetic dyestuffs.

iii. Natural dyestuffs produce rare colour ideas and are automatically harmonizing.

iv. Unlike non-renewable basic raw materials for synthetic dyes, the natural dyes are usually renewable, being agro-renewable/vegetable based and at the same time biodegradable.

v. In some cases like harda, indigo etc., the waste in the process becomes an ideal fertilizer for use in agricultural fields. Therefore, no disposal problem of this natural waste.

vi. Many plants thrive on wastelands. Thus, wasteland utilization is an added merit of the natural dyes. Dyes like madder grow as host in tea gardens. So there is no additional cost or effort required to grow it.

vii. This is a labour intensive industry, thereby providing job opportunities for all those engaged in cultivation, extraction and application of these dyes on textile/food/leather etc.

viii. Application of natural dyes has potential to earn carbon credit by reducing consumption of fossil fuel (petroleum) based synthetic dyes.

ix. Some of its constituents are anti-allergens, hence prove safe for skin contact and are
mostly non-hazardous to human health.

x. Some of the natural dyes are enhanced with age, while synthetic dyes fade with time.

xi. Natural dyes bleed but do not stain other fabrics, turmeric being an exception.

xii. Natural dyes are usually moth proof and can replace synthetic dyes in kids garments
and food-stuffs for safety.
Despite these advantages, natural dyes do carry some inherent disadvantages, which are
responsible for the decline of this ancient art of dyeing textiles.

Limitation/ disadvantages of natural dyes/ colouants

i. It is difficult to reproduce shades by using natural dyes/colourants, as these agroproducts vary from one crop season to another crop season, place to place and species to species, maturity period etc.

ii. It is difficult to standardize a recipe for the use of natural dyes, as the natural dyeing process and its colour development depends not only on colour component but also on materials.

iii. Natural dyeing requires skilled workmanship and is therefore expensive. Low colour yield of source natural dyes thus necessitates the use of more dyestuffs, larger dyeing time and excess cost for mordants and mordanting.

iv. Scientific backup of a large part of the science involved in natural dyeing is still need to be explored.

v. Lack of availability of precise technical knowledge on extraction and dyeing techniques.

vi. The dyed textile may change colour when exposed to the sun, sweat and air.

vii. Nearly all-natural dyes with a few exceptions require the use of mordants to fix them on to the textile substrate. While dyeing, a substantial portion of the mordant remains unexhausted in the residual dye bath and may pose serious effluent disposal problem.

viii. With a few exceptions, most of the natural dyes are fugitive even when applied in
conjunction with a mordant. Therefore, sometimes their colour fastness performance
ratings are inadequate for modern textile usage.